Expert View

How companies can build in-house consulting teams?

  • Structure the internal consulting team to attract a pool of potential CXO talent

Abhisek Mukherjee
Published13 Jul 2022, 01:47 AM IST
REUTERS
REUTERS

Management consultants support clients to take decisions and drive actions under uncertainty. Given the accelerated proliferation of uncertainty generating events over the last decade such as recessions and covid, consulting firms have had the best decade ever. This trend is expected to continue; existing clients will require more consulting services and new clients will enter the market.

Management consulting is expensive. The median billing range for India-bred consulting firms and the Big Four is 0.7-1 million per consultant-month. For international firms like Accenture, this range can be 1.5-2 million. For MBB (McKinsey, BCG, Bain,) the range is 2.5 million plus, and can cross 5 million per consultant-month (Indian arms of MNCs often pay global rates.) This translates to gross margins of more than 50%.

Given this increasing need for consulting services and the high costs, many companies attempt to build consulting teams in-house. At its core, management consulting requires three things: One, top talent. Two, access to information sources such as research reports and expert networks (e.g., GLG—Gerson Lehrman Group.) Three, institutional knowledge on domains and problem-solving methods.

Clients can access top talent either from consulting firms or from the same business schools that management consulting firms target. It is common for consultants to shift to their clients after a time. Clients can afford to pay top salaries as they save on the margins. This addresses the first point around top talent and the third point as such consultants bring in the required methodologies. Domain knowledge is not a challenge as clients tend to have experts in most areas in their businesses. On the second point, clients can contract directly with research firms and expert networks.

So, theoretically, any client that requires a meaningful volume of consulting services should be able to save significantly by building consulting teams in-house. Yet, in our experience, this often fails. At best, a small team is built which ends up managing the external consultants, yielding no meaningful savings.

Why does this happen? Our analysis indicates four main reasons:

The first reason is core versus periphery. In consulting firms, strategy is the core service and consultants are the key revenue earners. In contrast, in-house consulting teams are perceived as non-core support services and often treated as cost centres. This loss of primacy leads to frustration for in-house teams.

The second reason is identity. Being an employee of a top consulting firm ascribes a certain superior identity. In contrast, being a part of an in-house consulting team, even for a global brand, offers an identity that is relatively diluted. I have met strategy heads of MNCs who continue to draw their identities from their previous consulting employers instead of their current companies.

The third reason is the lack of internal competition. Top management consulting firms recruit insecure overachievers from some of the most competitive schools on earth and extend a similar environment at work. The brutal consulting pyramid, that enforces “up or out,” acts as a motivator that drives continued excellence. The relatively laid-back culture of internal consulting teams impacts this desire to excel. Ironically, this also impacts consultants who move to a corporate role for better work-life balance. The addictive adrenaline rush of consulting is hard to give up.

The fourth reason is lack of accelerated growth opportunities. In management consulting, it is common for top performers to become partners within ten years. In contrast, as internal consulting teams are perceived as support services, they offer lesser growth opportunities. Ex-consultants observe their colleagues from revenue-generating line functions overtake them and get disillusioned.

So, is there a way to make internal consulting teams work? We have noted only one approach that consistently works: Structure the internal consulting team to attract a pool of potential CXO talent. Make it clear that the internal consulting role is temporary to enable the transition from a consulting to a CXO career. This creates flux but addresses all the four challenges: It promises an accelerated path to a core CXO role, builds an identity as a high-potential leader and fosters internal competition.

Increasing uncertainties and growing consulting costs will force clients to consider in-house options. Structuring these as pools of potential CXO talent offer the best chance of success.

Abhisek Mukherjee , co-founder and director, Auctus Advisors.

Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

MoreLess
First Published:13 Jul 2022, 01:47 AM IST
Business NewsOpinionColumnsHow companies can build in-house consulting teams?

Get Instant Loan up to ₹10 Lakh!

  • Employment Type

    Most Active Stocks

    Bandhan Bank share price

    211.00
    03:51 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    23.25 (12.38%)

    Tata Steel share price

    160.70
    03:51 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    1.05 (0.66%)

    Axis Bank share price

    1,174.25
    03:29 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    -9.5 (-0.8%)

    Zee Entertainment Enterprises share price

    130.10
    03:55 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    0.7 (0.54%)
    More Active Stocks

    Market Snapshot

    • Top Gainers
    • Top Losers
    • 52 Week High

    JM Financial share price

    153.85
    03:51 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    8.75 (6.03%)

    Divis Laboratories share price

    6,141.15
    03:59 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    200.65 (3.38%)

    Page Industries share price

    45,400.00
    03:29 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    1264.7 (2.87%)

    HCL Technologies share price

    1,839.55
    03:57 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    29.55 (1.63%)
    More from 52 Week High

    Cummins India share price

    3,611.75
    03:55 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    -169.6 (-4.49%)

    Star Health and Allied Insurance share price

    547.85
    03:59 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    -19.35 (-3.41%)

    Creditaccess Grameen share price

    1,081.40
    03:29 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    -38 (-3.39%)

    Jubilant Pharmova share price

    1,146.15
    03:55 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    -37.65 (-3.18%)
    More from Top Losers

    Nippon Life share price

    700.85
    03:53 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    59.15 (9.22%)

    Network 18 Media & Investments share price

    81.44
    03:52 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    5.16 (6.76%)

    Sonata Software share price

    608.50
    03:42 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    36.1 (6.31%)

    Triveni Turbines share price

    790.10
    03:29 PM | 11 OCT 2024
    45.85 (6.16%)
    More from Top Gainers

    Recommended For You

      More Recommendations

      Gold Prices

      • 24K
      • 22K
      Bangalore
      76,645.00-50.00
      Chennai
      76,651.00-50.00
      Delhi
      76,803.00-50.00
      Kolkata
      76,655.00-50.00

      Fuel Price

      • Petrol
      • Diesel
      Bangalore
      102.86/L0.00
      Chennai
      100.76/L0.01
      Kolkata
      104.95/L0.00
      New Delhi
      94.72/L0.00

      Popular in Opinion

        HomeMarketsPremiumInstant LoanMint Shorts