3 min read.Updated: 05 Jan 2022, 10:21 PM ISTBloomberg
Social and other curbs have been enforced but poll rallies carry on
Listen to this article
Covid cases are surging in India. Still, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his political opponents are on the campaign trail. The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party plans the “biggest ever political rally" in the northern state of Punjab (which is also under a range of virus curbs). As many as 300,000 people were expected at Wednesday’s gathering, organizers told local media. Meanwhile, the capital, New Delhi, is under a strict night-time and weekend curfew. Its chief minister Arvind Kejriwal, who belongs to a rival party and is just back from heavy campaigning across the north, announced on Tuesday that he’d tested positive for the virus.
We’ve seen this movie before. In April 2020, as India reeled from a wave of hospitalizations and deaths and its citizens took to social media to beg for oxygen, a maskless Modi boasted of huge crowds at an election rally in the state of West Bengal. At the time, India had the world’s fastest rising covid caseload, and by the time the deadly second wave had run its course, experts estimated the country’s actual death toll ranged between 1.3 million to a staggering 5 million, three to 10 times the country’s official count.
Yes, this latest surge is probably mostly fuelled by the Omicron variant, and, yes, perhaps it is less deadly. But with a medical system as underfunded and rickety as India’s—public health spending is less than 2% of gross domestic product, compared to 5.4% in China and a global average of nearly 10%—this is still a recipe for disaster. Hospital admissions have begun to tick up and exhausted doctors and nurses are being called in from their winter leave to prepare for a spike in cases.
India’s democracy is often called raucous: Political rallies are enormous; its Parliament can descend into chaotic shouting matches (admittedly no different to others that operate under a Westminster-style system like the UK and Australia); and troll farms are notorious for their vehemence and reach.
But under Modi, politics has taken on a different tone altogether. Anti-Muslim hate speech and violence is on the rise; Christians are now also being attacked; and governments led by Modi’s BJP are either silent on these crimes, or worse, its members are sometimes active participants. Journalists are routinely labelled “anti-national," activists are jailed, and political opponents say institutions from the courts to the election commission have been stripped of their independence. It is in this climate that the Modi team has apparently determined that state election campaigns should continue, covid or not.
Health experts and epidemiologists are despairing. “The one thing we know for sure about Omicron is that it is significantly more transmissible than any of the variants that came before it—for this reason, anything that might promote transmission should be rigorously controlled, large gatherings among them," Gautam Menon, a professor at Ashoka University, told me. He lamented that India had not learned from what he described as “the devastating second wave," noting: “It is hypocritical to say that numbers at wedding parties should be restricted, but to impose no such curbs on political rallies."
India is not alone in its selective application of covid-safe rules for election events. In France, which is in the grip of a presidential campaign as virus cases escalate, compliance with pandemic measures is voluntary and each party has interpreted the guidelines differently, as the Financial Times reported.
Meanwhile, the frustrations surrounding India’s health data are as fresh as ever, two years into the pandemic. Scientists are still asking the Modi administration for vital information to track the epidemic and develop appropriate health responses, including genome sequencing for variants and more accurate death figures.
There is one silver lining, though. Omicron is hitting a population that’s been significantly impacted by the Delta variant and survived, while [a significant proportion] of the country’s adult population is fully vaccinated. The last sero-survey released in New Delhi, which was in November 2021, indicated that 97% of those tested had covid antibodies.
Still, this third wave is building into a crisis just as Indian families prepare to mark the death anniversaries of those who didn’t make it through the second wave. State elections are due to be held in February and March in Punjab, Uttarakhand, Goa and the critical state of Uttar Pradesh, which—with a population the size of Brazil’s—is seen as a bellwether for the 2024 general election. The failure of Indian governments at all levels to provide even the most basic health care to those in need could be fresh in people’s minds as they head to the polls.
Ruth Pollard is a columnist and editor with Bloomberg Opinion
Subscribe to Mint Newsletters
* Enter a valid email
* Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter.
Never miss a story! Stay connected and informed with Mint.
our App Now!!