Yogi Adityanath slams Rahul Gandhi attributing ‘accidental Hindus’ quote to Nehru, but the truth lies elsewhere…

Adityanath criticised Rahul Gandhi referring to a quote often attributed to Nehru calling himself ‘accidental Hindu’, but a fact check reveals the remark was first made by NB Khare in 1959.

Livemint, Written By Jocelyn Fernandes
Published29 Apr 2024, 11:54 AM IST
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has alleged that Congress leader Rahul Gandhi ' never remembered the atrocities of the Mughals.
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has alleged that Congress leader Rahul Gandhi ' never remembered the atrocities of the Mughals.(Hindustan Times)

Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has blasted Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and wrongly attributed a controversial quote to India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, in the process  charging that "they (Nehru-Gandhi family) call themselves accidental Hindus".

Speaking to ANI on April 29, the BJP leader said: "People who do not know the history and geography of India will definitely make such irrelevant comments. When I talk about Rahul Gandhi, I remember that once these people called themselves accidental Hindus."

Also Read | Rahul Gandhi talks about women's unpaid domestic labour; netizens applaud: ‘Indian male politician has…’

"India has a rich tradition and our sages, Maharajas, and every section of the society have contributed in their respective fields...Rahul ji never remembered the atrocities of the Mughals, who left no stone unturned to Islamise India...It is unfortunate that those who call themselves accidental Hindus cannot feel pride about India's heritage..." he added.

Did Nehru Really Say 'Accidental Hindu'?

As per a fact check by Alt News, the first reference to this alleged remark, "accidental Hindus", cropped up in 1959 and it is attributed to politician NB Khare. Academics credit Khare with having made this remark in reference to Jawaharlal Nehru.

Watch | Do Rahul Gandhi & Congress Really Want To Re-Distribute People's Wealth? | Mint Fact Check

The fact check found Nehru's own words on being a Hindu in the 1929 resolution by the Indian National Congress demanding ‘purna swaraj’ from the British. In his INC presidentlal speech at Lahore, Nehru said the following on being a Hindu:

"I was born a Hindu but I do not know how far I am justified in calling myself one or in speaking on behalf of Hindus. But birth still counts in this country and by right of birth I venture to submit to the leaders of the Hindus that it should be their privilege to take the lead in generosity. Generosity is not only good morals, but is often good politics and sound expediency. And it is inconceivable to me that in a free India the Hindus can ever be powerless.”

PM Modi takes 'Aurangzeb' jab at Rahul Gandhi

Adityanath's comments came as the BJP and Congress traded jabs after Prime Minister Narendra Modi alleged that Gandhi "doesn't remember people (Mughals) who destroyed our religious places".

Also Read | PM Modi's blitz on Rahul, Congress, says India doesn't become an autocracy if Yuvraj cannot automatically get power

To this, Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh accused Modi of "maliciously twisting" every statement made by Gandhi to "inflame communal passions".

Also Read | ‘PM Modi may soon shed tears…’ Rahul Gandhi says ‘prime minister seems nervous these days’

"The Prime Minister is gone beyond being pathetic. He maliciously and mischievously twists every statement of Rahul Gandhi to inflame, incite, and ignite communal prejudices and passions. His exit is inevitable and his realisation of that is making him more and more desperate. His campaign speeches are shameful really," Ramesh posted on social media site X (formerly known as Twitter).

Catch all the Business News, Politics news,Breaking NewsEvents andLatest News Updates on Live Mint. Download TheMint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

Business NewsPoliticsNewsYogi Adityanath slams Rahul Gandhi attributing ‘accidental Hindus’ quote to Nehru, but the truth lies elsewhere…
MoreLess